DECEMBER 1999, pages 67-69
Southern California Chronicle
Religious Scholar/Writer Karen Armstrong Receives
Muslim Public Affairs Council’s 1999 Media Award
By Pat and Samir Twair
British scholar and best-selling author of books on religion Karen
Armstrong received the 1999 media award of the Muslim Public Affairs
Council. Michael Wolfe, recipient of the 1997 MPAC for his “Nightline”
reportage of the hajj from Mecca, was master of ceremonies.
The award for presenting a positive image of Iran was presented
for the first time in 1992 to actor Morgan Freeman and the writer
and director of the Hollywood film “Robin Hood.” Others recipients
have included Spike Lee in 1993 for his film “ Malcolm X,”
and Peter Sellars for his artistic contributions to the Los Angeles
Music Festival.
In addition to Muhammad: A Biography of the Prophet, Armstrong
has written A History of God, which was translated into 30
languages, and Jerusalem: One City, Three Faiths. Her new
book, The Battle for God, to be published next March, deals
with fundamentalism among American Protestants, Iranian and Egyptian
Muslims and Israeli Jews.
In a Sept. 26 address to an audience of more than 300 in Los Angeles’
Bonaventure Hotel, Armstrong considered why the Western intelligentsia
holds so many negative perceptions of Islam.
“These views embrace the idea that Islam is a violent, militaristic
religion established by the sword, that it denigrates women and
holds back its followers from entering the modern world,” she noted.
“This belief was not arrived at by any process of reflection, but
rather, it has been ingrained into our concept of Muslim identity.
It began with the Crusades.”
Armstrong, who left a cloistered life as a Roman Catholic nun in
1969, stressed the role of the Crusades in the West’s emergence
from the Dark Ages and barbarism.
“Through its First Crusade, the West was making a comeback and
it was creating a new Christian identity,” she observed. “When a
people forge a new ethnic consciousness, they need a foil to measure
themselves against, to articulate what they are. The Muslims were
[seen as] everything the Christians were not.”
Although when the Christians entered Jerusalem in 1099 they slaughtered
30,000 people in two days, Anderson pointed out, “we still use the
word ‘crusade’ to connote a positive effort. This is an indication
of the profound tone the Crusades have left in our consciousness,”
although “on some level, Christians must have realized the Crusades
were flagrant actions in opposition to the tenants of the Gospels.”
Richard the Lion Hearted and Saladin seemed to have understood
and respected one another, she theorized, but all this changed by
the 16th century when Islam seemed incompatible with a new type
of civilization based on the investment of capital and the manufacture
of goods that could go on indefinitely.
By the 18th century, the Ottomans, who had been the most powerful
empire in the world, realized they could no longer compete with
Europeans, who were imbued with a new secularism and in possession
of many technical improvements. Meanwhile the West forgot that it
had been behind the Islamic world for centuries and came to assume
it had always been more technically advanced than the East.
Now, she said, “the West seems to ask why the Muslims can’t see
the Western way is better, so why don’t they change right away?”
Armstrong pinpointed the characteristics of the modernizing process
as a constant declaration of independence in religious, social and
scientific thought and constant innovation.
“The whole modernization process is skewed for the Muslim world,
which is dependent on Western know-how and Western aid,” she emphasized.
“If you’re trying to follow a cake recipe and you only have rice
instead of flour, you are going to get a different cake.”
Whereas the West has decided the struggles Muslims are going through
are due to some kind of flaw in their religion, Armstrong said,
there are cultural and historical reasons for the differences in
outlook.
“Muslims under their own impetus evolved ideas similar to ours,”
she said. “The Qur’an speaks for egalitarianism, a desire for justice
and community endorsement. Democracy could be germane to Islam.
The central core teaching of the Qur’an is that the poorest, the
least powerful, are to be respected.”
She noted also that “Muslims have suffered appalling setbacks over
the centuries—the Crusades, the Mongols. Yet the Muslims have always
found the resilience to come back.”
When the Washington Report asked the religious historian
for her opinion on the future status of Jerusalem, she replied that
Jerusalem, being the place where three monotheistic faiths “found
their God,” properly belongs to no one nation.
“It should be jointly administered because the point of a holy
city is that no one owns it. It belongs to God and therefore to
everybody.”
An honored guest at the event was Michigan Congressman David Bonior,
who asked all present to contact their congressional representative
and “look him or her in the eye and ask them to explain why it is
necessary to have an anti-terrorism law that breaks the Constitution
and condones the use of secret evidence.”
Representative Bonior, who has introduced legislation to repeal
the use of secret evidence, cited the case of Dr. Mazen al-Najjar,
who has been imprisoned in Florida since early 1997 without being
charged.
Egyptian-American Receives Nobel prize
The 1999 Nobel Prize for chemistry has been awarded to Caltech
professor Ahmed H. Zewail. His research has succeeded in freeze-framing
molecules by using ultra-fast laser probes that show how molecules
meet, mate and “divorce” in a process billions of times more fleeting
than the blink of an eye.
Zewail’s team of 15 researchers operate the “femtosecond” flash
camera he designed by bringing into focus events that previously
zoomed by in an unfocused blur. Before the Egyptian-born chemist’s
experiments were validated, the process of molecules moving together,
bonding and breaking apart was suspected but invisible to scientists.
Caltech chemist Jacqueline Barton, who is using Zewail’s technique
to track the motion of electrons as they travel through DNA, stated:
“Ahmed’s experiments allow us to see these processes directly. He’s
done outstanding science.”
Zewail’s femtosecond lasers eventually will be used to design medicines
and are being introduced into dentistry so that a hole can be drilled
so fast, the heat doesn’t register pain in the patient.
The Pasadena-based Zewail plans to visit Egypt with his wife, Deema,
and to donate some of his $960,000 prize money to the high school
he attended in Alexandria, which now carries his name. Egypt already
has issued a postage stamp in his honor.
“Three Kings” Gives Positive Image of Iraqis
We were dubious, but open-minded, when invited to a special screening
of the action film “Three Kings” at Warner Brothers Studios. After
all, the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) had issued
a statement of approval upon viewing the movie.
From the opening scene set in the Kuwaiti desert, we felt as if
we actually were witnessing what it must have been like for American
troops who had anticipated waging a war, but instead marked time
in base camps while the Iraqi army was destroyed by remote-controlled
armaments.
Early on, Capt. Archie Gates (George Clooney), Sgt. Troy Barlow
(Mark Wahlberg), Staff Sgt. Chief Elgin (Ice Cube) and Pvt. Conrad
Vig (Spike Jonze) take possession of a map revealing the whereabouts
of a hoard of Kuwaiti bullion in an Iraqi bunker near Karbala. They
go AWOL in a Humvee and cross the border into Iraq, planning to
return within hours with enough gold to last 10 lifetimes.
Screenwriter/director David Russell has turned out a dark comedy
with a moral that might be described as “Patton” meets “Indiana
Jones and the Temple of Doom.” What the G.I.s don’t take into consideration
is witnessing Saddam’s Republican Guard massacring Iraqi civilians
who are defying the Ba’athist dictator. As the Americans begin to
comprehend the Iraqis will be killed by Saddam’s troops, they become
more interested in saving them than grabbing the gold.
It is the portrayal of Iraqis as humans who are brave and worth
saving that makes this Hollywood action film unique. Credit should
go to Warner Brothers and Russell for hiring Iraqi consultants to
assess the accuracy of roles played by Iraqis.
Sayed Moustafa al-Qazwini, a religious leader in Orange County
who was born in Iraq and was there during the war and the subsequent
uprising against Saddam Hussain, advised on all cultural and religious
parts of the script. This included costuming. In one incident, he
lent his own robe and headdress to an actor who was playing the
role of a Muslim prayer leader.
Kaeid al No’mani, an Iraqi filmmaker who was a movie actor in Iraq
and now lives in Detroit, was on the set every day to coach actors
to speak in regional Iraqi dialects and use gestures typical of
Iraqis.
Commented “Three Kings” producer Charles Roven: “We were trying
to make a film that was entertaining, exciting and funny, but emotionally,
the audience had to understand why the G.I.s put aside their greed
to do the right thing. We needed Iraqi characters who were understood
and liked.
“Once we started the process of insisting on accuracy, all the
dynamics of the film improved. The lead actors could get into their
characters because they knew what the Iraqi civilians were going
through. We were constantly surprised that we were getting more
and more out of the script as the consultants told us what was accurate
or phony and how burial and religious rites should be conducted.
It was almost subliminal, but the actors were affected because they
were performing realistically.”
Syrians Honor Superstars
The Syrian Arab American Association staged its own Academy Awards
when it conferred two lifetime achievement awards upon two of its
most enduring stars: comedian Durade Lahham and actress Muna Wassef.
Also honored was singer Nour Mohanna. The gala took place Oct. 9.
The al-Ataa awards, designed by Syrian-American filmmaker Farouk
Ubaysi, were gold replicas of an ancient statue of a libation priestess
encased in crystal. Before the presentations, video biographies
of Lahham and Wassef, also prepared by Ubaysi, were shown which
highlighted the major comedies, plays and films of both stars.
Lahham earned a master’s degree in chemistry and taught high school
before launching a career in 1960 in comedies which satirize a poor
man’s lot in life. He has appeared in 25 films, seven TV series
and seven satirical plays including “Ghorba,” “Daia’t Tishreen,”
“Kasak ya Watan” and “Shaka’ek, al-Noman.” His 1985 film, “Al-Haddad,”
won him the best film award by the Egyptian Film Critics and the
Catholic Center in Cairo and the best script award by the Valencia
Film Festival.
In accepting the al-Ataa award, Lahham quipped that the video made
him appear older than his 40 years and 300 months. Noting that he
had traveled more than 15,000 kilometers from Syria to Los Angeles,
he remarked that judging by the audience, the unity of Arabs is
starting in Los Angeles.
“It is enough to be an immigrant, don’t add to all the challenges
by being divided,” he advised. “Even though I am happy tonight,
I am scared, fearful, that our homeland is not comprehending all
the capabilities of the immigrants living here.”
Wassef also launched her career in 1960 when she took the lead
role in the Armed Forces Theater production of “Green Perfume.”
She married film director Mohammad Chahin in 1963 and a year later
joined the National Theater in such productions as Moliere’s “Don
Juan.” She gained international recognition after Syrian-American
director Mustafa Akkad cast her in the leading female role as Hind
in “The Message.” She continues to star in Arab films and
soon will be in a TV dramatic series, “The Calling of the Mediterannean,”
in which she will play a scheming queen mother circa 2000
B.C.
As she addressed the audience of more than 400 spectators, Wassef
told them, “You have given me a great deal, and I fear I have not
given enough.”
She recalled the day more than a quarter of a century ago when
Mustafa Akkad told her he would bring Hollywood to her if she starred
in “The Message,” and now she had come to Hollywood.
SAAA President Mutaz Chichakley announced the association has purchased
land in Norwalk for a cultural center.
Muslims Join National Religion-Labor Conference
An extraordinary marker in time was made Oct. 8 to 10 as the faith
and labor movements reunited after more than two decades in a conference
preceding the biannual AFL/CIO convention in Los Angeles. This time,
Muslims were included.
John Sweeney, president of the AFL/CIO, spoke twice at the conference
and made it clear he intends to work hand-in-hand with religious
leaders of all faiths to raise the living standards of America’s
working poor. In fact, before the conference, the AFL/CIO set aside
$100,000 to be matched by the Catholic Campaign for Human Development
to open 20 new faith-labor coalitions in the country.
Dr. Muzammil Siddiqi, president of the Islamic Society of North
America, made history for American Muslims when he joined Los Angeles
Cardinal Roger Mahony, Rabbi Leonard Beerman, Rev. Dr. James Lawson
and Monsignor George Higgins in addressing more than 250 faith and
labor activists at the Los Angeles Biltmore Hotel.
Dr. Siddiqi’s comments on the Islamic view of worker’s justice
echoed the demands of labor leaders: dignity of workers; kindness
to workers; do not give them chores beyond their capacity; allow
them time for rest; and pay them proper wages.
“In fact,” Dr. Siddiqi told the audience, “the Qur’an says the
workers are to be paid before their sweat dries.”
“Hopefully,” he concluded, “we will implement these traditions
as Christians, Jews and Muslims working together in this country
where we have the opportunity to do so.”
One of the most disturbing statistics released at the conference
is that in Sweden, a CEO makes five to seven times the income of
a worker, whereas in the U.S., a CEO makes 419 times that of a laborer.
World Sacred Music Festival Opens in L.A.
At the same time American religious leaders were crying out for
workers to earn a living wage, the World Festival of Sacred Music
called by the Dalai Lama was opening in Los Angeles.
Two years ago, the Dalai Lama issued a plea for nations of the
world to usher in the new millennium with festivals of sacred music
that would transcend the violence and bloodshed of the cruelest
century yet, the 20th century.
Judy Mitoma, director of UCLA’s Center for Intercultural Performances,
accepted the challenge, volunteered her expertise, and within 18
months organized a festival that offered 87 musical and spiritual
events in Los Angeles from Oct. 9 to 17. All participating artists
covered the cost of their own performances.
On Oct. 10, more than 15,000 spectators gathered in the Hollywood
Bowl to hear the Dalai Lama and representative portions of the music
to be offered for the ensuing week.
For the first time ever, and to our delighted surprise, the Islamic
call to prayer was sung in the Hollywood Bowl by Gazan singer Ahmed
El-Asmer. The enormous audience sensed this was a sacred rendition
and no applause followed. Ali Jihad Racy’s group performed several
interpretations of Sufi music. His finale was “Tala’a al-Badro,”
the song Muslims sang in 636 as the Prophet Muhammad entered Mecca
after defeating the pagans.
Los Angeles was credited as kicking off the cross-cultural parade
of sacred music, but the initial celebration took place in Fez,
Morocco, during the final week of May. Smaller festivals are planned
for Chicago, Milan, London, Moscow, Stuttgart, Helsinki, Hiroshima
and Seoul. The world premiere of an 18th century opera, “Zenobia
Queen of Palmyra,” is scheduled this summer in Palmyra, Syria.
Pat and Samir Twair are free-lance writers based in Los Angeles.
|