Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, October/November
1998, pages 62-63
People Watch
Two Congressmen More Concerned With Building
New U.S. Embassy In Jerusalem Than Protecting Existing Buildings
By Lucille Barnes
At this writing four named suspects are in custody on
suspicion of involvement in the bombings of U.S. embassies in Kenya
and Tanzania in which at least 258 persons were killed and more
than 5,000 injured, or of involvement with renegade Saudi millionaire
Osama bin Laden, who is suspected of having financed the
bombings. In U.S. custody are Mohammad Saddiq Odeh, arrested
in Pakistan on the day of the bombings while he was in transit to
Afghanistan, Mohammed Rashid Daoud Owhala, arrested in Kenya
after he was wounded in the bombing, and Wadih el Hage, a
resident of Arlington, TX who was accused of having worked as Bin
Ladens personal secretary when Bin Laden lived in Sudan.
In German custody is Mamduh Mahmud Salim, accused
of being a top financial official and arms purchaser for Bin Ladens
organization. The State Department also has posted a reward of up
to $2 million for the arrest of another alleged Bin Laden associate,
Haroun Fazil, a native of the Comoros Islands.
In the wake of the bombings, U.S. Secretary of State
Madeleine Albright scrambled to explain why she had not protested
when Congress cut back on funds requested by the State Department
to harden more U.S. embassies against such attacks.
But for some Israel firsters in Congress it was business as usual.
Representatives James Saxton (R-NJ) and Brad Sherman
(D-CA) introduced a bill to force President Bill Clinton to
build a U.S. Embassy in Jerusalem, which, pending an Israeli-Palestinian
peace agreement, is not recognized by any major country in the world
as the capital of Israel, if the administration wants money to build
a U.S. embassy in Berlin, the new, world-recognized capital of reunited
Germany.
In their new book entitled A World Transformed, former
U.S. President George Bush and his national security adviser,
Brent Scowcroft, provide in alternating chapters their explanations
for why the U.S. ignored opportunities to continue negotiations
for a peaceful Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait in the hours just before
and after expiration of the Coalition deadline. Scowcroft wrote:
The unhappy reality of the situation, from my perspective,
was that an Iraqi withdrawal would leave us in a most difficult
position. Saddam could pull his forces back just north of the border
and leave them there, poised for attack. U.S. forces, on the other
hand, could not long remain in place. Scowcroft also wrote
that Bush was taken by surprise by the Iraqi invasion on Aug. 2,
1990 because, up until that moment, diplomacy seemed to be
working, if slowly.
On Aug. 28 U.S. Federal Judge Thomas Penfield ordered
the government of Iran to pay a total of $65 million in civil damages
for its alleged role in the kidnapping of three Americans in Lebanon
by Shii Muslim extremist groups in the late 1980s. Former
American University of Beirut comptroller Joseph J. Cicippio,
now 67, who was held in shackles for much of 51ã2 years, was
awarded $16 million and his wife, Elham Cicippio, was awarded
$10 million; Frank Reed, now 65, former headmaster of the
Lebanese International School, who was so badly beaten during the
three years and eight months he was held that his ribs were broken,
was awarded $9 million and his wife, Fifi Delati-Reed, was
awarded $10 million; and David P. Jacobson, former director
of the American University Hospital who was held for 17 months,
was awarded $9 million.
The judgment was made possible under legislation passed
by Congress in 1996 allowing U.S. citizens who are victims of terrorist
acts abroad to sue foreign countries in American courts if those
countries have been classified by the State Department as sponsors
of terrorism. There is little doubt in anyones mind
that Iran controlled the Hezbollah, which is responsible for the
kidnapping and torture of these men, said attorney James
J. Oliver, who represented the former hostages.
In March, another federal judge ordered Iran to pay
$247.5 million to the family of Alisa M. Flatow, a 20-year-old
American citizen studying in Israel, who was killed along with a
number of Israeli soldiers in the bombing of a bus en route to an
Israeli settlement in the Gaza Strip. The Flatow family now is seeking
to seize the closed Iranian embassy, built during the regime of
the Shah and one of the most ornate diplomatic establishments in
Washington, DC, and other Iranian real estate in the United States.
The State Department opposes these efforts, saying the assets are
in its custody and subject to international arbitration.
William Scott Ritter Jr., the longest-serving
U.N. weapons inspector in Iraq, resigned Aug. 26 after charging
that reluctance by U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, the
U.N. Security Council, and President Bill Clinton and U.S. Secretary
of State Madeleine Albright had turned U.N. weapons inspections
in Iraq into a farce. International relief workers in
Baghdad had criticized the aggressive attitude of the 37-year-old
former U.S. Marine intelligence officer and some of his colleagues,
and he had been described by the Iraqis as a cowboy
and a spy. On the same day that he announced his resignation, CBS
news reported Ritter was being investigated by the FBI for allegedly
sharing classified information with Israel. Ritter denied that he
had done anything wrong and said he would be exonerated.
An Israeli judge took a half-step toward resolution
of an extradition request by the state of Maryland for 18-year-old
murder suspect Samuel Sheinbein. The U.S.-born youth, whose
father, Sol Sheinbein, was born in British-mandated Palestine
and who was brought to the U.S. as child, fled to Israel and claimed
Israeli citizenship to avoid prosecution for the murder of 19-year-old
Enrique Tello Jr. The Israeli judge ruled that Sheinbein
was not an Israeli citizen, opening the way to U.S. extradition
proceedings.
Manhattan federal Judge Denise Cote released
39-year-old Abdelhaleem Ashqar Aug. 21 from federal detention where
he had been on a hunger strike for six months after refusing to
testify in secret grand jury proceedings investigating alleged money-laundering
in the United States by the Gaza-based Islamic Resistance Movement
(Hamas). Ashqar supporters said that although he was not a target
of the investigation, he told the grand jury he would rather die
than betray long-held and unshakable religious, political
and personal beliefs... and commitments to freedom and democracy
in Palestine. Ashqar had been kept alive by forced feeding
since June in the Westchester Medical Center in New York, where
his lawyers said his hands had been shackled to his bed to keep
him from removing feeding tubes. The lawyers said Judge Cote released
him after hearing testimony that further imprisonment would have
no effect in compelling Ashqar to testify.
Undersecretary of State Thomas Pickering, the
smartest man in Madeleine Albrights State Department, didnt
look so bright and shiny when he appeared Aug. 26 at the Foreign
Press Center in Washington, DCs National Press Building to
defend U.S. retaliatory attacks for the two embassy bombings. Muslims
certainly were killed in the embassy bombings which, under
Islam, are totally impermissible, totally unjustified, totally
reprehensible, Pickering said. Granted. However, in asking
for the understanding of Muslims around the world...of
the need for our response under imminent threat, he was dodging
the issue of why the U.S. had bombed a pharmaceutical factory in
Khartoum (in which, fortunately, no one was killed) but now wouldnt
agree to a Sudanese demand for a U.N. inquiry into U.S. charges
that the factory was making a component of nerve gas. Now its
clear why. The charge apparently was a mistake.
In the Middle East Ben Zion Netan ya hu, father
of Israeli Prime Minister Bin yamin Netanyahu and an early
supporter of the Revisionist movement that gave birth to Israels
Likud Party, said his son is trying to extricate Israel from the
Oslo Trap and prevent the creation of a Palestinian
state, according to the AFP news agency. In Jerusalem remarks released
Sept. 17, the elder Netanyahu, a university professor in Pennsylvania,
said the peace process and the Oslo accords concluded by his sons
predecessors have put the Jewish people and the state of Israel
in mortal danger.
Renegade Palestinian terrorist Abu Nidals
name figured prominently in the news in August. Since his 1974 expulsion
from the PLO, the 61-year-old terrorist, whose real name is Sabri
Al Banna, has headed an organization that killed moderate Palestinian
leaders; allegedly tried to kill Yasser Arafat; is suspected
of the 1991 assassination of top Arafat aide Abu Iyad; supplied
hit men for Middle Eastern dictators when Abu Nidal was living,
consecutively, in Tripoli (Libya), Baghdad, Damascus and back in
Tripoli; and killed 19 and wounded 120 civilians waiting to board
planes in the Vienna and Rome airports in December 1985. (He said
they were passengers checking in for planes bound for Israel but
was mistaken in both instances.)
Abu Nidal first was reported by the Arab and German
press to have been intercepted by Egyptian authorities while leaving
Libya, where he has lived in recent years, for treatment for cancer.
Later reports said he did not have cancer and had been working secretly
with Egyptian authorities to thwart terrorist actions in Egypt,
but was arrested when he stopped cooperating. The Washington
Post reported that an unnamed Clinton administration official
confirmed that Abu Nidal was in Egyptian custody.
King Hussein of Jordan, who is undergoing treatment
for cancer at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, turned over
power to his brother, Crown Prince Hassan, to dismiss the
Jordanian cabinet in mid-August, but barred the prince from declaring
war, signing peace treaties, or changing the constitution.
Also in mid-August Saudi Arabian King Fahd underwent
surgery to remove his gall bladder by a medical team headed by Dr.
Ted Pappas of Duke University. King Fahd later returned briefly
to the hospital for a checkup but was released shortly afterward.
His half-brother and designated successor, Crown Prince Abdullah,
who has been carrying out the royal responsibilities whenever
the King is incapacitated by failing health, planned to visit Britain,
France, Japan, China and the United States on a tour originally
scheduled to begin Sept. 16.
Lebanons best-loved singer, Fairouz, made
her first appearance in a quarter-century this summer at the Baalbek
festival, an annual series of summer performances set in the worlds
largest and best-preserved Roman ruins. She is now 65 and lip-synched
part of the time to her recorded music. She remains Lebanons
best-known symbol of co-existence and unity because of her refusal
to perform in any part of Lebanon so long as the country was divided
by civil war.
History repeated itself when Israeli forces used a helicopter
gunship to ambush and kill Hossam al-Amin, a top commander
of the Amal militia, in mid-August, setting off a retaliatory barrage
of rockets into northern Israel in which at least 19 people were
injured. A similar Israeli ambush in February 1992 killed Sheikh
Abbas Musawi, a Hezbollah militia leader, along with his wife
and five-year-old son. Hezbollah was believed to have carried out
as retaliation the bombing of the Israeli Embassy in Buenos Aires,
Argentina, in which 29 peo ple were killed, one month later.
Palestinian Bassam Eid said his Palestinian
Human Rights Monitoring Group has documented 40 cases in which Palestinian
businessmen have been accused of avoiding taxes and imprisoned for
up to four years until they pay money that never reaches the Palestinian
Authoritys Ministry of Finance. One of the witnesses, former
journalist Issam Feisel Ramzi, said he was held and tortured
for 14 months at the direction of Jericho special prosecutor
Ibrahim Amru, who called him a spy and warned him: I am
the judge, I am the court, I am the police, I am the Palestinian
Authority, all in an attempt to get him to make false charges
against others and pay a 30,000-shekel fine. He was released only
after his case came to the attention of Palestinian Authority Attorney
General Fayez Abu Rahme, a former human rights lawyer.
The Palestinian Authority carried out the first executions
in its brief history against brothers Raed and Mohammed
Abu Sultan. They were accused of killing brothers Madji,
32, and Mohammed, 30, al Khalidi at a wedding
celebration. The brothers were tried and sentenced to death the
day after the killings, and executed the following day. A third
brother, Faris Abu Sultan, was sentenced to death but the
sentence was commuted to life imprisonment. Of the convicted brothers,
Raed was a bodyguard to a general, Mohammad was a member of military
intelligence, and Faris was an officer with a security force. The
two murder victims were members of Yasser Arafats Fatah movement.
Nabil Abu Zaid, a Fatah official who witnessed the trial
and executions, told The New York Times, the Palestinian
people are in general fed up with all these people carrying guns.
We want to stop this. Bassam al-Khalidi, an older brother
of the murdered men and a senior official at the United Nations
office in Gaza, said he had issued an appeal to some 2,000 young
men of the Al Khalidi family that there be no more bloodshed. More
than 20 Palestinians have been sentenced to death by the Palestinian
Authority in the four years since it assumed power in Gaza, but
until now Arafat has allowed none of the executions to proceed.
Chief prosecutor Vural Savas in Tur keys
secular government has requested that fraud charges of misappropriating
$3.6 million in party funds be leveled against 12 of Turkeys
top Islamist leaders. Among the leaders he is seeking to prosecute
are former Prime Minister Necmettin Erbakan, who was forced
to resign by the Turkish military and who headed the now banned
Refah (Welfare) Party, and Recai Kutan, head of the Virtue
Party, to which former members of the Welfare Party have turned,
and which leads in public opinion polls looking toward next Aprils
Turkish election. Seven of the accused are Virtue Party members
of parliament, and therefore hold parliamentary immunity. Islamist
politicians expressed the hope that the resignation of Gen. Ismail
Hakki Karadayi as Turkish chief of staff, and his replacement
by Gen. Huseyin Kivrikoglu at the end of August will initiate
a change in the hard line the military is pursuing against the Islamist
movement.
In South Asia, the last few years have been bad for
most Pakistanis, except perhaps the lawyers. But this year is even
bad for them. Former Prime Minister and Peoples Party leader
Benazir Bhutto complained in an Aug. 29 letter to human rights
organizations that not only has she been facing persecution
at the hands of the present regime, but now police have arrested
her defense counsel, Babar Awan, on charges of robbery,
after the editor of an Urdu newspaper charged Awan and a companion
seized a briefcase from him at gunpoint. Benazir, who is facing
at least a half- dozen charges of corruption, said authorities had
kidnapped another counsel, Pir Mazharul Haq, then detained
yet another lawyer, Abu Bakar, three times to delay court
orders for Haqs release. Her main counsel, Farooq Naik,
has been barred from traveling abroad, and her senior counsel
is ill. How can I brief lawyers or get defense when counsel
are repeatedly threatened with arrest? she asked in her letter.
Bhuttos husband, Asif Ali Zardari, has
been in jail on corruption charges since she was dismissed in November
1996 on charges of misrule and corruption. The lawyers community
in Rawalpindi suspended work to hold a protest meeting and procession
demanding the release of her lawyer. The following day, however,
a Pakistani court rejected a Bhutto petition to stop the Pakistani
government from discussing money laundering charges against both
Bhutto and Zardari with Swiss bank officials. |