wrmea.com

March 1997, pgs. 8, 84

Special Report

Pollster John Zogby Becomes “The Polltakers’ Poster Boy”

by Richard H. Curtiss

 “All Hail Zogby, the pollster who conquered the 1996 election…In polling getting it right is the best revenge. And that’s exactly what Zogby did last week.”—Public Opinion Analyst Richard Morin, Washington Post, Nov. 10, 1996.

Pollster John Zogby’s telephone has seldom stopped ringing in the three months since the November elections. At that time his biggest contract was for polling in the United States for London-based Reuters News Service. Now, after getting the 1996 presidential elections just right, and beating all his competitors in a crowded field, he already has a Reuters contract for polling in Canada and Latin America, and is receiving other offers daily.

Although home base for his organization, Zogby International, will remain in his home town of New Hartford, a suburb of Utica, NY, Zogby also is opening an office in Washington, DC. And his expanding corporate work now includes marketing surveys for major clients from coast to coast.

Zogby already had been in the polling business for several years when his results in 1994 New York elections confounded his competitors but proved to be right in the end. Big-time national recognition came, however, only after the votes were counted in the 1996 election. From early in the campaign, his polls predicted Bill Clinton would win by a much smaller margin than any of the other major pollsters were showing. Their derision grew as the gap widened.

The Zogby poll’s final numbers, however, were uncannily accurate because he not only got Clinton’s eight-point winning margin right, but also was the only pollster who got the numbers for Bob Dole and Ross Perot right as well. Most of his chagrined competitors, like Richard Morin of The Washington Post, quoted above, were gracious. Others, like The New York Times, whose CBS/ New York Times final poll had predicted Clinton would win by an 18-point margin, were not. It printed a compilation of final polling figures from different organizations that, by obscuring the extent of Zogby’s triumph, masked how far off base the final CBS/Times poll results had been.

Other daily newspapers were less grudging, even if they had printed the less accurate figures of other organizations. Wrote Jim Norman in USA Today, from which the figures in the accompanying box were taken:

“In a year when almost every poll overestimated President Clinton’s 8 percentage point margin of victory, one pollster was on the money. John Zogby, a newcomer to presidential polling, projected Clinton would win 49 percent of the vote to Bob Dole’s 41 percent, Ross Perot’s 8 percent, and 2 percent for others. Those were the exact outcomes of Tuesday’s vote.”

“Zogby, a maverick, is the landslide election winner of the polling contest of 1996,” wrote the Seattle Post Intelligencer. “Not only did he call this year’s presidential race right, this David also beat the Goliaths in 1992.”

Deborah Orin, Washington bureau chief for the New York Post, said, “I have now seen him do three races that almost everyone but him got wrong. I’m a great fan, but he has lots of great fans.” Immediately after the election she reported: “Only two polls came close—Reuter pollster John Zogby… and the ‘Hotline’ newsletter poll… Zogby also came closest of any pollster in this year’s New Jersey Senate race, where he polled for the Post and predicted Rep. Bob Torricelli would win by 8 points.

“At one point Zogby recalls being told that Clinton political director Doug Sosnik had suggested the pollster should hire ‘a professional.’ Now Zogby is laughing. ‘The profession was there all along, but I guess they couldn’t find anybody with the credentials to see it,’ he said.”

Wrote the Cleveland Plain Dealer: “(Washington professionals) love John Zogby, whose polls for the Reuters news service provided shreds of good (and, as it turns out, accurate) tidings during the campaign. Republican parents will be naming their children Zogby for a year.”

Zogby, whose brother, James Zogby, is president of the Arab American Institute in Washington DC, was on the staff of the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), also in Washington DC, before he returned to New York to open his polling company years ago. Although his polls were welcomed by the Republicans, he personally is a liberal Democrat. He attributes his success to his efforts to base his results on a more accurate portrait of Americans who actually vote. He uses screening questions to ferret out those Americans, and discards interviews with all others.

He also is innovative in reaching a real cross section of the voting public. This involves calling during a broader daily time period than do most other pollsters, thus catching shift workers and retirees that other firms may miss. In building his polling base he seeks to base predictions on accurate representations of political party registration, and he instructs his telephone bank callers not to push undecided voters into giving a premature answer.

His hometown newspaper, the Utica Observer-Dispatch, noted that “Zogby has become a phenomenon—and a little controversial—in the network of wonks, pollsters, pundits and experts that make handicapping political races its business.” It also sought his reaction to the instant fame.

“I’m getting to learn what it’s like when an actor becomes a star in a sitcom,” Zogby told Observer-Dispatch reporter John Kohlstrand. But, though few seemed to notice it, he pointed out, “we’ve been here and we’ve been growing and we’ve been doing good work for a number of years.

Having humbled the mighty New York Times and CBS poll, Zogby, who only a few years ago was dismissed by one competitor as “that Arab pollster,” now finds himself being interviewed by Rush Limbaugh and the major networks. And although he knows he’ll be studied by his competitors between now and 1998, he refuses to take himself too seriously.

“Eighty percent of this business is science,” he told his media interviewers, “and 20 percent is art.”

Pollster

Clinton

Dole

Perot

Victory
Margin

CBS/New York Times

53%

35%

9%

18%

Pew Research

49

36

8

13

ABC News

51

39

7

12

Harris

51

39

9

12

NBC/Wall Street Journal

49

37

9

12

USA Today/CNN/Gallup

52

41

7

11

Hotline/Battleground

45

36

8

6

Reuters/Zogby

49

41

8

8

Actual Results

49

41

8

8