February/March 1996, Pages 3, 98-102
Letters to the Editor
Letters to the editor are selected, edited and abridged on the
basis of relevance, accuracy, taste and available space. The editors
do not have facilities to respond to individual letters, or to clear
in advance published letters, as edited, with the writers.
Billions of Dollars Ripped Off
The Washington Report is, in my view, the best and most
informative publication in the U.S. I am particularly interested
in how a small country, as is Israel, is getting away with ripping
off billions of dollars from American taxpayers. I will be
running for the U.S. House of Representatives in 1996. The Israeli
rip-off will be the top priority issue for me in Congress. The knowledge
that I have acquired, by reading the Washington Report these
past years, has given me an excellent view on international affairs,
which I feel will give me a definite advantage over the other candidates.
Thank you for what you are doing for our country!
Thomas K. Shannon, Salinas, CA
Why Not Just Black and White?
The Washington Report is unique--in its approach, its scope
(topical and geographical), its focus on the issues, its insights
and knowledgeability, its commitment, its fairness and integrity.
I have every issue on my bookshelf, and I use it and cite it in
my writing and lectures. I have profound respect and admiration
for the publisher, executive editor, and several writers whom I
have long known personally. May the WRMEA not only endure
but prevail!
I wonder, however, if so many color pages are worth the costs.
I'd rather see black and white plates than lots of color photos
and have you go bankrupt!
Prof. Colbert C. Held, Waco, TX
Kind words from a distinguished veteran of both the foreign
service and academia like you help keep us going. Your question
is a good one. We hope the extra costs of color pages get us better
placement on newsstands and in libraries, which are prime sources
of new subscribers, along with gift subscriptions from loyal readers
like you. Our policy on such gift subscriptions is, after 12 months,
to send the renewal notice to the recipient rather than the donor,
freeing you to look for new recipients of gift subscriptions the
following year. Thanks for your encouragement and for the gift subscriptions.
Your Coverage is Fair
I just want to thank you for your publication. It is the only one
that keeps me informed and in touch with what is going on in the
Middle East. I can read it knowing that the coverage is fair. Keep
up the good work.
Jumana Nabali, San Diego, CA
Your Voice in the Wilderness
Your publisher, the American Educational Trust, is the voice crying
in the wilderness. Is it heard? Yes. Is it effectively heeded? Perhaps,
eventually.
I have always, since 1943, been inclined to the view that the Jewish
state that became Israel would destroy itself: unfortunately causing
much grief to others until the inevitability is sustained.
The Zionists' hope "to prevail by putting Islamic fundamentalism
at the throat of decadent Christianity" will not be realized,
just as Leninism eventually failed.
John Lawrence, Trenton, MI
Many Hours of Insight
Please forgive me that I do not find myself in a position to make
a donation to your invaluable publication this year, but remain
assured that as soon as Allah wills and my financial situation changes
for the better, I will think of you and the many hours of insight
you provide me through the Report.
At this time, I would like to wish your staff and their families
a very safe and enjoyable holiday season, all the best, and with
the following thought:
Together, we will let the voice of truth be heard and it shall
sing as loud as the trumpets of Jericho, and that same truth shall
set free all those who accept it and welcome it into their emboldened
hearts, for it is a truth that will rend asunder all the foundation
of lies that for years has become accepted in the eyes of many as
the only truth. This is my Christmas wish and New Year's resolution,
that not only my life, but that of all humankind, shall be liberated
by truth and truth alone.
Mohamed Mikeal Hammoud, St. Thomas, Ontario, Canada
Classy and Truthful
Yours is the classiest, most provocative, most truthful, and best
buy for the money of any magazine I have ever subscribed to. I agree
with you on practically everything and disagree with you on virtually
nothing. Keep up the good work.
Robert Schwarz, Altoona, WI
We Appreciate Your Efforts
Our donation is made on behalf of both my husband and myself,
in appreciation of your efforts in promoting a more fair and just
U.S. Middle East policy, and to ensure continuing the publication
of the Washington Report--the only voice in the wilderness
of media bias.
Permission is granted to publish both of our names in hopes
it will serve as an incentive to other ARAMCO annuitants also to
contribute to AET support.
Carter and Beverly Swartz, Sarasota, FL
U.S. Interests in the Middle East
Other resources do not provide me with an alternative point of
view, particularly regarding U.S. political interests in the Middle
East.
For a country that prides itself on providing information--much
of that information is not always accurate. Your magazine is a breath
of fresh air. Thanks.
Farida Sweery, Charlotte, NC
Providing Information
You stand alone in providing information as to what goes on in
Washington regarding the Middle East.
Name Withheld
You're right, and frankly we sometimes feel lonely until
we start going through the mail and find a lot of journalists who
wish they had our freedom to call things the way we see them.
I'll Help to Spread the Word
I am in receipt of your recent appeal for donations and have forwarded
its copies to my friends in New Jersey asking for donations on behalf
of the Washington Report. I would also like to subscribe
to the Washington Report for three friends of mine (addresses
enclosed), two of whom will be running for Congress in 1996 from
the 3rd district of New Jersey. Kindly send them each a free copy
of the book Assault on the Liberty and charge $57 for the
three donated subscriptions to my American Express account.
As you are aware, I am a staunch supporter of your efforts to educate
and inform the American public about facts concerning the United
States' Middle East policy. It is not an easy job by any standards
because of the clearly biased and pro-Israel media. The job requires
an enormous amount of resources, commitment and courage considering
the well organized efforts to put out misinformation and the existence
of the most-feared Israeli lobby. I have no doubt that you deserve
an A-plus for your efforts so far. I for one was never so well informed
of the facts before I started reading the Washington Report
and can't imagine having to live without this fine magazine.
May I suggest that you consider (1) increasing the number of issues
to 12-a-year; and (2) increasing the annual subscription to $25?
While this increase might result in cancellation of a few subscriptions,
I am certain that the majority of your readers will gladly pay the
small additional amount.
Waheed Khalid, Ouro Preto, Brazil
We're planning to follow your second piece of advice, starting
with our next issue. The first is harder because until we develop
some staff redundancy it would mean our editors no longer could
travel to the Middle East and still be around to put out each issue.
(At present our executive editor goes three or four times a year.)
However, with supporters like you we'll someday get there. Thanks.
A Belief in Brotherhood is Lacking
This is a difficult letter to write but I feel you should have
a reply to your request.
We have tried for more than half a century to promote peace in
the Middle East without success. Isn't it time to try a new tack?
Brotherhood is the warp and weft of peace, but Israel doesn't believe
in brotherhood. So why do we continue to give them our time? We
are working at cross purposes. This is not productive. Our doting
attitude is not appropriate.
E.K.S. Judge, Arnold, MD
Ignorance About Mideastern Christians
I am a student at the University of Michigan. Recently I had to
write a term paper on American public opinion toward the Middle
East. Of course one of my main sources was the Washington Report.
I would like to see more articles about Christianity in the Middle
East, because not many in this country know that there are Christian
Arabs.
Finally, I want to make a comment about your Dec. 1995 issue.
In "Letter from Lebanon," you refer to the head of the
Maronite Church as Monsignor. I think the term Cardinal or Patriarch
would be better.
Nijad Mehanna, Dearborn, MI
Thanks for the kind words and for setting us straight. We'll
make the change in the disk now in preparation that will contain
all of our past issues and also make them available through our
web site on the Internet.
Middle East Peace is Just a Beginning
Moved by a deep and long-term concern for the Jewish and Arab people,
I have prepared the enclosed papers in an effort to help. I hope
you will read them thoughtfully and consider what use can be made
of them. Perhaps you can suggest persons or organizations to whom
I should send them.
Peace should not be considered a final goal but rather a necessary
step in dealing with the profound social, economic and ecological
problems of the Middle East.
For example, in 1950, when I was an administrator of Arab relief
in the Gaza Strip, the population there included 70,000 native inhabitants
plus 200,000 refugees. Today the population in the Gaza Strip totals
over 800,000. In the surrounding nations, too, the population has
more than doubled, and the explosion goes on apace. Water and arable
land are limited. Economic problems grow and poverty multiplies.
Peace is necessary, but is just a beginning. What is called for
is a close-knit community of nations, working together as a team.
Failing in this, the Middle East faces disaster.
I hope you will use your influence to help bring about this desperately
needed community of nations.
Ernest Morgan, Burnsville, NC
P.S. You've touched a lot of lives and made a lot of friends over
the years. We're all pulling for you now.
We are publishing one of the two papers you enclosed as a "Point
of View" on page 45 of this issue.
Uncensored Reporting
I like the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs because
I get more uncensored and unbiased reporting--in other words, unslanted
news.
Crystal English, Portland, OR
Cut the Emphasis
You are providing important information, but let the facts speak
for themselves. There is too much zealotry in your presentation.
I agree with you on the need to cut U.S. aid to Israel and
Egypt. I disagree with you when you are too "preachy"
on the Israel-Palestinian issue. You're not giving us enough of
both sides of the story on Arab mistreatment of other ethnic groups.
Angela Dickey, Arlington, VA
You Have Courage
Your magazine is very informative and addresses issues of concern
to me. You provide a voice of courage and reason that is needed
to balance the tide of stereotyping and disinformation.
Eid B. Mustafa, Wichita Falls, TX
Overlapping and Overkill
My interests pretty well cover the spectrum. However, there is
a lot of overlapping in your publication and perhaps some overkill
on the subject of Israel and surrounding issues. In other words,
there is some overload in some areas and under-reportage in some
of the pivotal nations and issues in the Middle East such as Algeria,
Turkey, Iran and Kashmir.
I agree with you on most issues, but I think you need to be more
even-handed on Iran.
Cleve D. Shearer, Bonners Ferry, ID
A Request for Stamps
I saw in the March issue of the Washington Report that the
Palestinian National Authority has issued some stamps. Two were
illustrated. If possible, would you please send me one of each.
My daughter is a stamp collector and she would like to have one
each of all their stamps.
I would gladly pay for them if you would let me know the cost.
You have a great magazine. Keep up the good work. I always look
forward to the next issue.
Ray F. Dively, Baden, PA
By the time you read this you will have received one Palestinian
five-mil stamp affixed to our annual fund-raising letter to subscribers.
It is the only stamp we have received. We'll try to report in our
next issue on PNA plans for future issues. (The PNA is banned under
the Oslo agreement from issuing its own currency, although under
the British Mandate there were Palestinian banknotes, coins and
postage stamps.)
You're the Palestinian Voice
You provide a great service. The Palestinians need a voice in the
United States and you're it! It must be that reason will one day
prevail and you will have accelerated its return to U.S. Middle
East policy.
Tom Velela, Washington, DC
The Cranbrook Good Guys
I was recently privileged to be one of two discussants at a presentation
by Dr. Hanan Ashrawi in Detroit. The occasion was the annual dinner
of the Cranbrook Peace Foundation, a local group of good guys who
run various programs. They bring in a famous person once a year
to speak to their members and to the general public. There were
about 800 present. In the past they have brought in Nobel Prize
winners Oscar Arias and Elie Wiesel. This year, the speaker was
Hanan Ashrawi. One of the discussants was Jeff Kaye, an Israeli
on a three-year assignment in Detroit to facilitate cooperative
cultural exchanges with the Jewish community. He is a high school
principal who is a strong supporter of the peace process. He presented
a moving personal perspective. I was the other discussant, chosen
because I am neither Israeli nor Palestinian, and because I could
bring an American academic perspective.
Enclosed are my comments. I don't know if they would be of use
to WRMEA or not. Keep up the good work.
Ron Stockton, Dearborn, MI
You will find your wise, dispassionate and eloquent remarks
on p. 24 of this issue. We would guess you will be invited to participate
in many more such discussions.
Retirees Speak Up
You do great work. We are retired and living on a fixed and limited
income, hence cannot afford gift subscriptions. We're renewing ours,
however.
Elizabeth Bernstein, Paradise, CA
With a slight increase in subscription prices scheduled for
this spring, we are a bit worried about long-time subscribers for
whom the jump from $19 to $25 might be a problem. If it is, call
our circulation department.
An "Accidental" Attack on USS Liberty
As the enclosed article in the International Journal of Intelligence
and Counter-Intelligence shows, Mr. David Rodman, a university
professor in New York, would have liked for everyone to believe
that the attack on the Liberty was an accident. His attempt
backfired.
I wrote the article in response to Rodman's book review--as opposed
to a full-length piece--but the publisher chose to present it as
a main feature. If I had known he was going to do that, I'd have
put in one or two thousand more words.
The piece will soon be in cyberspace ( USS Liberty web page).
Because Israel's loyalists will be calling me a liar and an "anti-Semite,"
I'll be getting "on line" so that I can enjoy their reaction.
If you all have a Web Page and would like a disc, I'll gladly send
you one. You can also simply refer your readers to Jim Ennes's web
page--it has 2,500 pages of information.
Reverdy S. Fishel, Arlington, VA
We're happy you didn't add one or two thousand more words because
in its present compact form your article fits into our expanded
"Other Voices" section. We will request permission from
the IJIC to reprint it in our April issue. Washington Report
readers interested in learning more about the IJIC, a quarterly
whose subscription price is $45 for individuals and $75 for institutions,
may contact the Journal c/o Intel Publishing Group, Inc.,
Box 188, Stroudsburg, PA 18360. Jim Ennes' award-winning USS Liberty
web site may be found at http://www.halcyon.com/jim/ussliberty
Non-Arabs Must Speak Up
I have lived in this area for 30 years and, if you keep past files,
you will see my enthusiastic letter to Ambassador Killgore and USIS's
Richard Curtiss when they started the Washington Report in
its early newsletter format several years ago. I have subscribed
to the Report ever since and donated it to as many of my
friends as I can think of so, as usual now, my contribution is to
be used where you feel it will be most effective.
It is extremely important, in my opinion, that non-Arabs speak
up for the Palestinian cause and that the extent of U.S. support
for Israel is revealed to the American people. I wish flyers could
be sent into each and every American home at this time when so many
Americans are hurting economically!
I am strongly against the Israeli-Palestinian peace treaty. It
is a complete sell-out to Israel. I am also against the current
U.S. interference here in the Middle East on all fronts and am extremely
suspicious whenever a new conflict arises between countries around
us. I am of American nationality but ashamed of being an American
here in the Middle East. I understand why they feel they have to
barricade themselves in their embassies, consulates and compounds.
I am happy to see more and more people are becoming involved in
the Washington Report and that most of them are non-Arabs
and some of them are Jews. Hopefully more and more influential Arabs
will become involved in the political arena and will be heard on
U.S. campuses and elsewhere.
As I know you are aware, Khaled al Maeena is the most articulate
and well-informed voice in the English-language local press on Palestine,
Bosnia and most other issues which ought to be the concern of all
fair-minded human beings.
I am originally from Norway, a country which sponsors Israel, at
least in the recent past, on purely fundamentalist religious grounds!
I might suggest that you try to give subscriptions to Norwegian
key reporters. Perhaps Gro Brundtland could benefit from a year's
subscription to the Washington Report.
With my sincere appreciation for your efforts and best wishes,
Else Rennes Bogary, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
We have trouble getting the Arab News, which carries
Khaled al Maeena's weekly column, in Washington but, as you know,
we do frequently select one of his columns for inclusion in our
"Other Voices" section. We'll use part of your donation
to the American Educational Trust for a subscription for Prime Minister
Gro Brundtland.
Indecipherable Rubbish
The Washington Report on Middle East Affairs is perhaps
the only tool available to me with in-depth coverage that allows
me to make up my mind on what to do. Without your facts and interpretations
everything else available to me is indecipherable rubbish.
Name Withheld
Anger, Frustration and Pain
Anger, frustration, pain! That's just how I felt when I found out
about yet another House Report (104-295) that was being attached
to the Fiscal 1996 Foreign Operations Appropriations Bill (HR1868).
Within these documents there is an act entitled "Middle East
Peace Facilitation Act of 1995." There are seven pages. The
Sense of Congress section is really upsetting. Section 603 states
that the PLO must do far more to demonstrate an irrevocable denunciation
of terrorism and ensure a peaceful settlement of the Middle East
dispute. This is just one condition. There are a whole series of
others in order to receive United States financial assistance which
is standard for any recipient. I assure you that there are no such
conditions imposed on the Israelis. Section 603.2 goes on to mention
that since the Declaration of Principles was signed, violence has
caused the deaths of over 140 Israeli and U.S. citizens. I could
not believe the gall of this factoid. If we want to play the numbers
game, the Palestinians have witnessed close to 225 deaths at the
hands of the IDF et al. during the same time period.
It is clear to me that the lobbyists got to our elected officials
once again.
Robert J. Pisapia, Westlake Village, CA
What is even weirder is that the lobbyists who got to our elected
officials ostensibly represented Israel's opposition Likud party.
Yet somehow AIPAC, which totally controls the votes on Middle East
affairs of perhaps 90 percent of the members of both houses, and
which supposedly represents any elected government of Israel, doesn't
seem able to rein in the Likud lobby. Maybe, to reposition itself
for a Likud victory in November 1996, AIPAC isn't trying very hard.
Or maybe the Labor government of Israel doesn't really care that
much about whether the Palestinians get their agreed pittance, so
long as Congress goes on appropriating Zillions for Zionists.
U.S. Policies Far From Rosy
The Washington Report gives me a sense of the views of the
non-Zionist American establishment on Middle East-related issues.
It is an excellent alternative media to the rubbish they call mainstream.
However, I often think the publishers are too eager to put a rosy
face on U.S. policies, which are as bad as ever, as far as the masses
in the Middle East are concerned.
In general I agree with you on exposing the Zionist lobby's control
of Congress. I disagree with you on unsupported optimism.
Raif Hijab, Berkeley, CA
Actually, there are times when we agree with you on both
counts.
Arabs Should Be More Aggressive
I regret to say that the Arab community (publications included)
don't seem to take the offensive to present the truth about Arabs/Islam,
e.g. (1) the fact that when Jews were being persecuted by Christians
(which they were, constantly) the Jews found homes in Islamic countries;
and (2) the myth that Arab-Jewish enmity has existed for centuries.
I agree with your policy of having diaspora and Israeli Jews contribute
articles.
Nabih J. Sarkes, Fayetteville, NC
Fungible U.S. Funds for Israel Factory
Intel is soon to build a huge plant in Israel and the Israeli government
has pledged to contribute $400 million toward the construction costs.
Money being fungible, why is the American taxpayer borrowing
$3 billion plus, annually, in order to provide the money as an annual
gift to Israel? Not only are we not benefiting from
the jobs and tax revenue from Intel, which is taking advantage of
this situation, but our taxes are paying for the project.
That isn't my only gripe. Americans who make contributions to Israeli
causes receive a tax deduction. This is a unique benefit not
granted to other citizens willing to make donations to their favorite
foreign nation or cause.
Then there is this unsettling revelation on C-SPAN last fall by
ex-Mossad officer and best-selling author of By Way of Deception
Victor Ostrovsky. He stated that Israeli goods and products are
shipped to the United States tariff free; a unique arrangement through
Israel's sayanim and Zionists in Congress. This has converted
Israeli shippers into distribution, repackaging and relabeling centers
for huge amounts of Russian, European and Third World products--re-exported
to the U.S. under Israeli labels. Again, the U.S. Treasury is denied
hundreds of millions in lost import duties and fees at the expense
of the American taxpayer.
Given Zionism's influence on the media, I assume the Washington
Report is the only vehicle for this complaint.
Joseph H. Kress, Lt. Col. USAF (Ret.), Summerville, SC
Unfortunately, your assumption seems to be correct. For new
readers, because Israel has free-trade arrangements with both the
U.S. and with the European Union and other countries, it can "springboard"
products made in one area into the other while circumventing customs
duties both ways. The tax deductions are possible because of a unique
law that grants U.S. tax-exempt status to all Israeli organizations
that have Israeli tax-exempt status. These are just additional ways
to extort more benefits from the U.S. Treasury for Israel, which
in addition to all of this now receives more than one-third of the
U.S. world-wide foreign aid budget, plus $2 billion in U.S. government
loan guarantees annually. As a result of all these "entitlements"
at the expense of U.S. taxpayers, Israeli government sources believe
Israeli per capita income now approaches and may soon exceed U.S.
per capita income.
"And For What?"
"And for what?" I quote the closing line from an article
by noted columnist Anthony Lewis in a recent issue of your magazine.
Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, who lived by the gun, died by the
gun. His goal was to drive out the Palestinian people at any cost:
Breaking bones, subjecting these people to inhuman indignities while
hiding behind the religious edict of the highest power.
And for what? Golda Meir suggested that all of Palestine was a
land without people and the Jews were a people without a land. God
willing this could be resolved. But the tenacity of the Palestinians
had not been fully measured. At this writing the road back to civility
is well on its way and the 50 or more years of the occupation and
subjugation are nearing an end.
Now, I ask God, and for what?
To help it all come true, I send a donation.
Elmer V. Mayer, Heber Springs, AR
Brzezinski's Reminiscence
On the day after the Rabin assassination, CNN had an interview
with Zbigniew Brzezinski, National Security Council chief under
President Jimmy Carter, for memories of Rabin. He told of suggesting
to Mr. Rabin after the Camp David Accords in 1978 that it would
be a good time to make an offer of land for peace to the Palestinians.
Mr. Rabin said that he felt the Palestinians needed another 20 years
first to be shown who was in control.
It is ironic that Rabin, who came to recognize the importance of
negotiated settlement so recently, is commonly regarded as the man
of peace, while Arafat, who recognized that about 20 years ago,
is not!
Karin Brothers, Toronto, Canada
Rabin, the "Peacemaker"
Last month we all read, watched and heard much about Yitzhak Rabin.
We were told hundreds of times that he was a hero, a peacemaker,
a noble and righteous man. However, as a Palestinian, I would like
to say that I have a totally different image of Mr. Rabin, and I
believe that I have the obligation to let my opinion be known.
I first would like to make it clear that I am against the killing
of someone over his or her opinions. I truly believe that dialogue
and discussion are the proper channels for people to voice their
opposition and disagreements with each other. However, what disturbed
me the most about the media coverage of the Rabin assassination
is the untrue image it generated of him.
I grew up in Palestine, where I spent most of my life under Israeli
occupation and control. When I think of Mr. Rabin I always think
of the man who started his military career with both the Haganah
and the Palmach terrorist groups which oftentimes entered Palestinian
villages and terrorized unarmed civilians. In one such attack on
the village of Deir Yassin, near Jerusalem, the groups killed most
residents of the village, including elders, men, women, children,
and even unborn babies inside the wombs of their mothers. This incident
was fortunately reported by an international observer who was in
the area; otherwise it would have gone untold like many other Israeli
massacres. Sadly enough, in its coverage of the prime minister's
assassination, the media referred to his unholy involvement with
the Haganah and the Palmach as a positive contribution for the liberation
of the Jewish people. I honestly wonder about the type of liberation
this was?
When I think of Rabin, I think of all of the power and freedom
which has been enjoyed by the extremist West Bank settlers who have
always gone around the holy land killing innocent Palestinian men
and women, and in some cases children under the age of five. Under
Rabin's government the Israeli settlers, especially in Hebron, have
constantly gotten away with their murders without being punished
or put to trial for their evil actions. It is only now, after murdering
their leader, that a few of them are being interrogated and put
in prison.
When I think of Rabin, I think of the Israeli leader who up to
the moment he died insisted on continuing the imprisonment and the
torture of thousands of Palestinian men inside the Israeli jails.
In many instances, Rabin was the main figure who refused the release
of innocent prisoners; especially the ones who opposed the Israeli/PLO
agreement.
Less than a week before Rabin was killed, Fathi Shakaki, a Palestinian
figure, was assassinated by, according to some foreign reports,
what could have been the Israeli intelligence. When Rabin received
the news of Shakaki's death, he said: "If it was indeed [Shakaki]
who was killed, I certainly won't be sorry about it." At this
moment, similar to Mr. Rabin's comment about Mr. Shakaki, I would
like to say that Mr. Rabin will not be missed by me or by the majority
of my people. We have only lost one of our oppressors.
Omar Imam, Columbus, OH
We hesitate to add anything to the reports of an eyewitness
to such events in a demonstrably terroristic occupation which has
ignored the Fourth Geneva Convention and other provisions of international
law to which Israel is a party. However, the conventional wisdom
on the attack on Deir Yassin is that it was planned and initiated
by two Jewish underground groups: Menachem Begin's Irgun Zvai Leumi,
and Lehi (the "Stern gang"), one of whose three commanders
was Yitzhak Shamir. The role of Haganah in the attack, as we understand
it, was to provide artillery cover. Whether there is a qualitative
difference between lining up and shooting or knifing to death men,
women and children in and near their homes, as did Begin's and Shamir's
subordinates, or blowing them to bits in their homes from afar as
did Rabin's comrades, we don't know. Quantitatively, it was all
the same, a lot of dead bodies which the perpetrators tried to hide
not by burying them (too many) but by dousing them with gasoline
and setting them afire, where they continued to smoulder long enough
to be seen by eyewitness survivors and international observers.
We must also add that Fathi Shakaki was the leader of Islamic Jihad,
suspected of engineering bombings of civilian buses in Tel Aviv
and Jerusalem, therefore neither better nor worse than Begin or
Shamir. The only difference is that Shakaki was assassinated (obviously
on Rabin's orders), Begin died in his bed and Shamir remains active
in his political party, Likud.
Newt Gingrich: Misinformed Or Misleading America?
True or false? Of the 184 U.S. embassies located in various countries,
only the U.S. embassy in Israel is not located in the country's
capital.
If you answered true, you're wrong. But don't feel bad. House Speaker
Newt Gingrich failed this test too, if a recent statement he made
indicates his knowledge of the subject.
The facts are that there are seven countries in which the U.S.
embassies are not located in their capital cities. Israel is not
one of them. They are:
The case of Israel's capital is a special one. Although the Israeli
parliament in 1950 declared Jerusalem its capital, it did so in
defiance of U.N. Resolution 181 (recommending a partition plan for
Palestine). Not only that, the decision also reneged on a 1949 pledge
not to have sovereignty over any part of Jerusalem Israel made to
the U.N. General Assembly--an assurance given to meet the Assembly's
condition for Israel's acceptance as a U.N. member.
An overwhelming majority of the international community, including
the United States, have not recognized Israel's unilateral action.
That is why, in Israel, the embassies of the U.S. and all other
countries, except for El Salvador, Costa Rica and Zaire, are located
in Tel Aviv.
The question becomes why isn't Mr. Gingrich better informed on
this subject? Has he been lied to, or is he deliberately trying
to deceive the American people?
Let us give him the benefit of the doubt.
That is why I would urge the speaker's staff to help him become
better informed by using the State Department's list of Key Officers
and Foreign Service Posts for embassy locations and comparing
those cities with the capitals listed in the Independent States
and Dependencies Fact Sheet issued by the State Department's
geographer.
Both documents are available to the "Third Wave" speaker
and all others from gopher://dosfan.lib.uic.edu, the World Wide
Web site
http://dosfan.lib.uic.edu/dosfan.html, or at most local libraries.
Issam M. Nashashibi, Newport Beach, CA
Incorrectly Named
The caption on page 11 in your December 1995 issue is in error.
I've met Hanna Siniora. He is the man standing, with glasses.
An Iran-born acquaintance has alleged to me that the People's Mojahedin
are Islamic Marxists who are under the influence of Saddam Hussain
and will impose tyranny upon Iran. Whenever 100 congressmen endorse
a group, my eyebrows rise.
Finally, a lawyer friend represents an Israeli Jew here who resists
return to Israel on grounds that she will be denied freedom as a
practicing Buddhist. Do you know of a useful precedent or the address
of Attorney Linda Brayer, a South African-Israeli convert to Catholicism?
Anthony Saidy, Los Angeles, CA
We don't know the answers on Jewish Israelis who convert to another
religion so we have sent you separately Linda Brayer's phone and
fax numbers. Perhaps someone who knows more about the subject would
like to do an article for us.
We stand corrected on Hanna Siniora and are doubly chagrined
because we've met him too. Finally, we have no vested interest in
any particular faction in Iran's political spectrum. If the People's
Mojahedin gets a larger share of our space than others, it's because
it does more, far more, than others. From our Washington, DC perspective
it seems, literally, to be the only organized opposition group that
actually has members. Other resistance organizations seem to have
leaders but no rank-and-file followers. We're willing to stand corrected,
but we've been scanning the horizon, in vain, for more than a decade.
Is Maryam Rajavi the Only Solution?
I wrote to thank you for your article revealing the facts about
the National Council of Resistance of Iran [Washington Report
editor's note: The People's Mojahedin of Iran is the major component
of the National Council of Resistance] and its president, Mrs. Maryam
Rajavi.
As an Iranian professional and business owner in the United States,
my greatest wish, like millions of Iranians around the world, is
to see freedom and democracy established in Iran. After many years
of research and observation, like many Iranians, I have come to
the conclusion that the National Council of Resistance, with its
elected president, Maryam Rajavi, is the only solution to end the
shameless dictatorship of mullahs' rule in Iran. I commend your
executive editor and the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs
for taking a step in writing the truth about Iranian people and
their hopes.
Hopefully, with more insightful articles like yours, people as
well as leaders in the Western world will realize the true dynamics
of Iranian culture and the best of its achievement. Mrs. Rajavi
has joined the resistance against the most brutal regime in the
history of mankind.
Jalal Arani, Annandale, VA
The Iran Trade Embargo
Keep up your great magazine and don't change a thing.
I get angry with the Israeli lobby in Washington, e.g: the Iran
trade embargo, the U.N. sanctions on Iraq and the settlements being
increased on confiscated land.
Nick Vangelis, Chicago, IL
Keep Up Your Endeavors
Your excellent efforts do keep me informed. Best wishes to you
in your endeavors.
Fuad Boali, Bowling Green, KY
A Cover-to-Cover Reader
The Washington Report is a wonderful source of information
about what is going on in Israel/Palestine. I read it from from
cover to cover.
Louise Green, St. Louis, MO
We fear that as the magazine gets larger, that may be harder
to do. Anyway, we promise not to give our cover-to-cover readers
pop quizzes.
To Put it Simply
Simply put, yours is the only publication I have come across that
deals with the Israeli-Palestinian issue in a comprehensive and
fair manner. Most major newspapers and other publications are so
emphatically pro-Israeli or too scared to upset American Jews and
be called "anti-Semitic." Although to most Americans a
lot of what you discuss may just not be interesting, as an American
who has traveled and lived in the Middle East, it is to me.
Richard Makdisi, Berkeley, CA
Your Writers Inspire Me
The Washington Report provides a unique forum for dispensing
the wisdom of Andrew Killgore, Richard Curtiss, Alfred Lilienthal,
Israel Shahak, Grace Halsell, Paul Findley and many others. It is
an inspiration (and a challenge) to read accounts by experienced
persons who have dedicated their lives to truth and justice. Thank
God for each of you.
Linda Long, Mount Crawford, VA
I Want to Help
I appreciate your information about congressional and White House
Mideast involvement. I would like to donate to Palestinian causes.
Would you list responsible agencies that handle donations?
Dr. Robert J. Fritz, Schenectady, NY
We do carry advertisements for some of those agencies and we
don't accept such advertising unless we believe that the money is
being used as depicted. However, we'll try to put together an article
giving an overview of such groups, and what each of them does. Thanks
for the suggestion.
Your Focus is Significant
I can assure you that the Washington Report is the most
significant reading material in my present life. Without it I'd
feel hopeless, without focus and depressed. If you ask me, I would
like a 148-page issue 12 times a year, and at a higher rate, perhaps
$30. Keep up the good work and may god bless you all!
Mohamed Aslam, The Colony, TX
This issue is our first at 140 pages, and we plan to raise the
annual subscription rate to $25 in April. But then we'll hold for
a while and get used to the new workload while our subscribers get
used to the $6 increase. Gift subscriptions we'll hold at $20.
My Faith is Preserved
The Washington Report is invaluable in preserving my faith
in the existence of justice. I agree with you on virtually everything.
Marietta H. Sharp, Washington, DC
Thanks for the Truth
Thank you for giving us the truth on the Middle East situation.
Thank you for exposing the cost to U.S. taxpayers of the blind support
of Israel's disregard for international law; Israel's total disregard
for the human rights of non-Jews in the Holy Land; and the frightening
control of our government by Zionism and the Israeli PACs.
Name withheld, Milwaukee, WI
Connecting Readers to Groups
The best thing about the Washington Report for me is that
it connected me to the world of Muslim and Arab-American activists.
I found out about all kinds of groups, resources and activities
of which I otherwise wouldn't have been aware.
E. Fadali, Reno, NV |